Discover why thorough manuscript editing is the foundation of a successful self-published book.

Manuscript editing: The foundation of a flawless self-published book

Building a house requires careful planning and the right materials. Imagine handing a mason a pile of unsorted bricks, warped wood, and cracked tiles, and telling them to start building. The result would be a chaotic, structurally unsound mess.

Similarly, for self-publishers, your manuscript is the raw building material of your book, and just like construction materials, it needs to be meticulously prepared before it ever reaches the design stage. Thorough manuscript editing is not just recommended; it’s absolutely crucial for a smooth, cost-effective, and professional publishing journey.

Hire the Best Freelance Proofreaders

Check out Proofreaders with the skills you need for your next job.

The manuscript: Your book’s blueprint and building material

Before your words ever grace the pages of a beautifully designed book, they exist as a manuscript in a text programme like Microsoft Word. This is the stage where every comma, every sentence, and every paragraph needs to be perfected.

Think of it as the detailed blueprint and the sorted, high-quality building materials for your literary house. Just as a mason relies on perfectly cut and prepared materials, your graphic designer relies on a meticulously edited manuscript.

The cost of post-design edits: Rebuilding a house

Once your book moves into a design programme such as QuarkXPress, Adobe InDesign, Illustrator, or even Canva, it transforms from raw text into a visually structured product with specific page layouts, fonts, and graphics. This is akin to the actual construction of your house. Once the walls are up and the roof is on, making significant changes becomes incredibly challenging and expensive.

Unlike Word, where changes to copy often automatically reflow text and adjust page numbers, design programmes are not built for extensive text editing. When you make changes to the copy in a design programme, especially once the pages have been laid out, the consequences can be far-reaching and frustrating:

Text reflow chaos

Adding or deleting even a single word can throw off the entire layout of a page, or even multiple pages, creating a cascade of design issues.

Widows and orphans

You’ll likely encounter instances of “widows” (a single word or short line appearing at the top of a column or page) and “orphans” (a single word or short line appearing at the bottom of a paragraph at the top of a new column or page). These small typographic errors make a book look unprofessional.

Inconsistent spacing and design elements

If your graphic artist initially adjusted spacing, tracking, or leading to fit text perfectly, any subsequent text edits will undo these precise adjustments, leading to inconsistent spacing and requiring manual readjustment.

Graphic artist frustration and redesigns

The graphic artist, who has already invested time and skill in perfecting the layout, will have to spend significant additional time redesigning pages, manually renumbering hundreds of pages in a long book, and fixing the ripple effect of your edits. This leads to immense frustration and can strain the professional relationship.

Budget blowouts

Remember the mason? Every extra hour they spend fixing structural issues due to faulty materials adds to your bill. Similarly, graphic artists often charge for these extensive post-design edits, and some companies even charge almost the same price to make corrections as they did for the original design of the book. This means you could effectively be paying for the design process twice.

Effective steps for a flawless manuscript

To avoid these costly and time-consuming pitfalls and ensure a smooth collaboration with your graphic artist, take these crucial steps to edit your manuscript thoroughly before submitting it for design:

1. Self-edit rigorously

Don’t underestimate the power of your own critical eye. After completing your first draft, step away from the manuscript for a few days, or even weeks, if possible. This allows you to return to it with a fresh perspective, making it easier to spot errors and areas for improvement that you might have become “blind” to during the writing process.

Read your manuscript multiple times, focusing on different aspects each time. On one pass, look only for typos and grammatical errors. On another, scrutinise plot consistency and character development. A third pass could focus on sentence structure, awkward phrasing, and eliminating repetitive words or ideas. Reading your manuscript aloud can also help you catch clunky sentences and unnatural dialogue.

2. Utilise editing software

While not a substitute for human editing, grammar and spell-checking software can be incredibly helpful first-line defences. Start with the built-in tools in your word processor (like Microsoft Word’s spell check and grammar suggestions).

For a more robust analysis, consider investing in or trying free versions of advanced AI-powered editing tools like Grammarly, ProWritingAid, or even Hemingway Editor. These programmes can identify common errors, suggest stylistic improvements, highlight overused words, and provide insights into readability, saving you time and catching mistakes that might otherwise slip through.

3. Get beta readers

Before sending your manuscript to a professional, enlist the help of beta readers. These are trusted individuals (friends, family, or members of a writing group) who read your manuscript and provide feedback from a reader’s perspective. They can point out areas where the plot is confusing, characters are underdeveloped, pacing is off, or where the emotional impact isn’t landing as intended.

Beta readers offer invaluable insights into clarity, coherence, and overall readability that you, as the author, might be too close to see. Ensure you get feedback from diverse readers to get a well-rounded perspective.

4. Hire a professional editor

This is an investment that will pay dividends in the long run. A professional editor is trained to identify and correct errors that even the most diligent self-editor or beta reader will miss. Depending on your manuscript’s needs, you might hire:

Developmental editor: Focusses on the big picture – plot, character arcs, pacing, theme, and overall structure.

Line editor: Concentrates on the prose style, flow, word choice, and sentence structure, making your writing more engaging and impactful.

Copy editor: Addresses grammar, spelling, punctuation, capitalisation, consistency (e.g., proper nouns, numbers, hyphenation), and factual accuracy.

Proofreader: The final safeguard, catching any remaining typos, formatting errors, or minor inconsistencies before publication. A professional editor brings an objective, expert eye, ensuring your manuscript meets industry standards and presents your work in the best possible light.

5. Final proofread of the manuscript

Even after a professional editor has worked on your manuscript, a final proofread by you is essential. No editor is infallible, and sometimes new errors can be introduced during the editing process (e.g., formatting glitches).

This final read-through is your last chance to catch any lingering typos, awkward phrasing, or minor inconsistencies before the manuscript is handed over for design. Print out your manuscript and read it slowly, perhaps even backward, to break up your reading patterns and catch errors you might otherwise skim over.

6. “Lock down” your content

This is a crucial communication step with your graphic artist. Once you have completed all stages of editing – self-editing, beta reader feedback, professional editing, and your final proofread – declare your manuscript “locked”. This means the content is finalised, and no further changes to the text will be made.

Communicate this clearly to your graphic artist. This allows them to proceed with the design phase confidently, knowing that the foundation (your text) is stable. Any changes requested after the design process has begun will incur additional costs and significant delays, as explained in the main article.

How to Become a Proofreader: Skills, Salary, and More

Interested in proofreading jobs? Here’s what you should know, including essential proofreading skills, helpful certifications, and more.

Conclusion

Whether you’re self-publishing on Amazon KDP, IngramSpark, Barnes & Noble, or any other direct publishing platform, your success hinges on presenting a polished, professional product. By investing the time and effort into thorough manuscript editing before your book reaches the design stage, you’ll not only save yourself significant money and headaches but also foster a positive working relationship with your graphic artist. Remember, a perfectly edited manuscript is the strong, stable foundation upon which a beautiful and successful book is built.

____________________