Mother’s Day spending: What moms really want vs what we buy.

The shocking truth about Mother’s Day spending – are you overdoing it?

Mother’s Day is a time to celebrate the incredible women who shape our lives, but in recent years, the holiday has become synonymous with extravagant spending. Consumers in the US alone shelled out a staggering $35.7 billion in 2023, according to the National Retail Federation (NRF). But here’s the shocking truth: many of us are overdoing it, equating love with dollar signs rather than meaningful gestures. Are you falling into the trap of overspending? Let’s dive into the data, uncover hidden trends, and explore how to honour Mum without breaking the bank.

Last Minute Gifts For Mother’s Day | Virgin Experience Days

No matter how many times we tell ourselves we’ll be prepared for Mother’s Day, it always springs up on us. Luckily, we’re here to save the day with our collection of last minute gifts for Mother’s Day.

The rising cost of celebrating Mum: When did love become so expensive?

Mother’s Day has transformed from a simple celebration of gratitude into a multi-billion-dollar spending frenzy. Over the past decade, the cost of honouring Mum has surged dramatically, with the average American now spending $274 per person—a staggering increase from the $168 average spent in 2010. But where is all that money going? Breaking down the billion-dollar spending habits

The National Retail Federation (NRF) reports that consumers collectively poured $35.7 billion into Mother’s Day in 2023, with the biggest splurges falling into four key categories:

Jewellery ($7.8 billion) – Diamond earrings, engraved pendants, and luxury watches top wish lists, making jewellery the single most expensive gift category.

Special outings ($5.6 billion) – Lavish brunches, spa retreats, and weekend vacations have become the new norm, as families try to outdo previous years’ celebrations.

Flowers ($3.2 billion) – Classic roses and elegant lilies remain timeless favourites, with premium custom bouquets driving up costs.

Electronics ($3.1 billion) – Surprisingly, tech gifts like smartwatches, tablets, and voice assistants are gaining traction, especially among younger, digitally savvy moms.

The pressure to spend: Guilt, social media, and commercial influence

Despite these eye-popping numbers, a troubling trend has emerged: nearly 40% of consumers admit they feel pressured to overspend, while 1 in 4 even take on debt just to keep up with expectations. The rise of social media has exacerbated this issue, with picture-perfect gift reveals and extravagant gestures setting unrealistic standards. Retailers, of course, fuel the fire—Mother’s Day marketing campaigns now start as early as March, pushing premium products with emotional messaging like “She deserves the best.”

But here’s the real question: When did love become measured in dollar signs? The original intent of Mother’s Day—a heartfelt tribute to maternal bonds—has been overshadowed by commercialisation. While gifts and gestures are wonderful, the true cost of this holiday isn’t just financial—it’s the stress, debt, and misplaced priorities that come with equating spending with affection.

Is this what Mother’s Day should really be about? Or is it time to rethink how we celebrate the women who matter most?

The emotional vs financial value of gifts

Mother’s Day has become synonymous with extravagant displays of affection—lavish gifts, luxury brunches, and eye-catching flower arrangements. Yet beneath the glossy marketing lies a surprising truth.

According to a survey by YouGov, a significant 76% of mothers would prefer a heartfelt, homemade gift over an expensive store-bought item. This highlights a growing disconnect between emotional value and financial outlay. While many assume that spending more translates into showing more love, most mothers, in reality, place far greater importance on sincerity, thoughtfulness, and time spent together.

Experiences over material gifts

One of the clearest findings from recent studies is that experiences hold far more value to mothers than material objects. Many say that simple, shared moments—such as a picnic in the park, a family game night, or even a handwritten letter—carry more emotional weight than a luxury handbag or jewellery.

These moments foster connection, nostalgia, and a sense of being truly appreciated. In contrast, material gifts often fade in significance over time, while memories created through shared experiences are cherished for years to come. It’s a powerful reminder that authenticity often trumps opulence when it comes to expressing love.

The “guilt spending” effect

For many adult children, especially those living far from home or caught up in hectic lifestyles, Mother’s Day becomes a trigger for guilt. This emotional response can lead to “guilt spending”, where individuals feel compelled to overcompensate for their absence throughout the year by splashing out on pricey gifts.

Retailers are quick to capitalise on this mindset, offering “perfect” gifts with hefty price tags. However, such gestures may miss the mark emotionally. While the intention may be pure, mothers often just want to feel remembered, not compensated with expensive items.

The social media influence

In the age of Instagram and TikTok, Mother’s Day has become another opportunity for people to perform their affection online. Photos of elaborate gift arrangements, luxury brunches, and flower walls flood social media feeds, setting a high—and often unrealistic—standard for what a “proper” celebration looks like.

This pressure fuels a cycle of comparison and excess, where individuals feel the need to spend more simply to keep up appearances. The result? A celebration rooted more in performative consumerism than in personal, meaningful gestures. For many mothers, a quiet moment of connection would be far more welcome than an Instagram-worthy spectacle.

The truth? Thoughtfulness, not cost, is what mothers cherish most.

Mother’s Day getaway ideas | Perfect breaks and days out for Mum | lastminute.com

Plan the ultimate Mother’s Day getaway with our top picks for relaxing escapes and fun-filled adventures. Treat your mum to…

How to celebrate without overspending

Mother’s Day doesn’t have to come with a hefty price tag. In fact, some of the most memorable and meaningful gestures cost very little, if anything at all. By shifting the focus from financial expenditure to emotional connection, you can create a truly heartfelt experience for the one who gave you everything. Here are some thoughtful, budget-friendly ways to celebrate Mum without breaking the bank.

Handwritten letters & memory books

In an age dominated by digital communication, a handwritten letter holds a unique charm. Taking the time to write a heartfelt note or assemble a scrapbook of shared memories shows thoughtfulness and effort.

Whether it’s a series of thank-you notes tucked into an envelope, or a handmade memory book filled with old photographs, mementoes, and personal anecdotes, these keepsakes become treasures. They remind Mum not just of the past, but of the strong bond you continue to share. Such gifts often become more cherished than any store-bought item.

DIY gifts & personalised crafts

Homemade gifts carry a warmth that money simply can’t buy. Baking Mum’s favourite cookies, crafting a bespoke photo frame, or even creating a simple herb garden together can mean far more than a generic gift set.

These kinds of gifts show you’ve invested your time and creativity—two of the most meaningful currencies in any relationship. Whether you’re knitting a scarf, making scented candles, or putting together a family recipe book, the result is something truly unique and personal that reflects your relationship with her.

Quality time over lavish outings

The pressure to book high-end brunches or spa days can be overwhelming, but the reality is that many mothers would rather spend quality time with their children in a relaxed, personal setting. Why not prepare her favourite meal at home, light some candles, and turn the living room into a makeshift bistro? A cosy film marathon with her top movie picks or an afternoon walk in the park can create a far more intimate and meaningful experience than a crowded restaurant. It’s not about where you are—it’s about being together.

Subscription services that keep giving

Not all gifts need to be one-off purchases. Thoughtful subscription services can offer long-term joy without the high price tag. For example, an audiobook or podcast subscription for as little as £5 a month allows Mum to enjoy new content tailored to her interests throughout the year.

Whether she’s into crime thrillers, gardening tips, or mindful meditation, there’s something out there for everyone. These small monthly gestures can feel like a continuous reminder of your love and thoughtfulness well beyond Mother’s Day.

Charitable donations in her name

If your mother has a strong philanthropic spirit, consider making a charitable donation in her name to a cause she deeply cares about. Whether it’s a local animal shelter, a cancer research foundation, or an education charity, this gesture aligns with her values and extends the celebration beyond your household. It not only honours her nurturing nature but also helps those in need—a beautiful way to reflect the true spirit of motherhood.

The dark side of Mother’s Day commercialisation

While Mother’s Day should be a celebration of gratitude and love, it has increasingly become a playground for marketers. Since 2020, advertising spend around this holiday has surged by 22%, with retailers keen to exploit emotional triggers for profit. Shoppers are bombarded with messages suggesting that more expensive gifts equate to deeper love.

However, research consistently shows that material gifts offer only fleeting happiness. In contrast, emotional connections—be it through experiences, quality time, or meaningful conversation—create long-lasting joy. It’s important to step back from the commercial pressure and remember that what mothers value most isn’t extravagance, but authenticity.

MasterClass Google Chrome 2020 04 08 19.43.09 1024x597 1

MasterClass: Learn from the best

LEARN FROM THE WORLD’S BEST The greatest have something to teach us all—at any level. Watch world-class instructors share their stories, skills, …

Learn More

Final thought: What would Mum really want?

Before swiping your credit card, ask yourself: Is this gift truly for her, or am I buying into societal pressure? The best celebrations focus on love, appreciation, and presence—not price tags.

This Mother’s Day, break free from the spending frenzy. Give her what she truly desires: your time, your attention, and your love.

_______________________

PlayStation®5 Pro Console - 30th Anniversary Limited Edition Bundle

Every month in 2025 we will be giving away one PlayStation 5 Pro. To qualify subscribe to our newsletter.

When you buy something through our retail links, we may earn commission and the retailer may receive certain auditable data for accounting purposes.

Sweet TnT Magazine Trinidad and Tobago Culture

The shocking truth about Mother’s Day spending – are you overdoing it?

Related Articles

The rising cost of celebrating Mum: When did love become so expensive?

The pressure to spend: Guilt, social media, and commercial influence