From Pagan rites to Easter delights: The secret hot cross buns history.

Hot cross buns history: A timeless Easter tradition with ancient roots

Discover the history, symbolism, and a step-by-step recipe for perfect homemade hot cross buns.

Historical origins of hot cross buns

Hot cross buns, spiced sweet buns marked with a cross, trace their roots to ancient pagan and Christian traditions.

Sweet TnT 100 West Indian Recipes

Sweet TnT 100 West Indian Recipes is your kitchen guide to cooking in the Caribbean. Kindle US$4.99/Paperback US$29.99

Pagan beginnings

In 9th-century England, the Saxons celebrated spring festivals dedicated to Ēostre, a goddess of dawn, fertility, and renewal. These festivities marked the vernal equinox, a time of rebirth in nature, and featured rituals to honour her influence over the burgeoning life of the season. Among these traditions was the baking of round, sweet buns adorned with symmetrical crosses.

The cross, etched into the dough before baking, held dual symbolic meaning: some scholars suggest it represented the four phases of the moon, aligning with Ēostre’s lunar associations, while others argue it signified the intersection of the seasons or the sprouting of new life.

These buns, likely made with honey and seasonal grains, were both offerings to the goddess and communal sustenance, blending spirituality with the practical joys of harvest. This practice underscored the deep connection between agrarian cycles and pagan belief systems, embedding food as a sacred medium in seasonal rites.

Christian adaptation

By the 12th century, the Church sought to Christianise pagan customs, and the humble bun was reimagined as a symbol of Christ’s sacrifice. Monks recast the cross-adorned treat as a devotional food for Good Friday, linking it to the crucifixion.

The once-pagan emblem now evoked the cross of Calvary, while ingredients gained theological resonance: spices like cinnamon and nutmeg alluded to the embalming spices used in Jesus’ burial, and currants or raisins mirrored the Eucharistic bread’s simplicity, echoing the Last Supper.

Known as “Hot Cross Buns”, they were distributed to the poor as acts of charity, blending piety with communal care. This transformation exemplified the Church’s strategy of repurposing familiar traditions to ease conversion, ensuring the buns’ survival by grafting them onto Christian liturgy.

Tudor turbulence

The buns’ religious symbolism sparked controversy during the Protestant Reformation. In 1592, Queen Elizabeth I, seeking to suppress Catholic practices, banned their sale outside of Easter, Christmas, and funerals. The decree targeted their association with “popish superstition”, particularly the belief that Hot Cross Buns baked on Good Friday possessed magical properties or could avert evil.

Yet the prohibition backfired, fostering a clandestine culture of home baking and secret exchanges. This rebellion against authority only deepened the buns’ cultural resonance, transforming them into symbols of resistance and continuity. By the 17th century, despite official censure, the buns had become entrenched in British folklore, their survival a testament to the enduring power of tradition amid shifting religious and political tides.

EXPLORE THE COMPLETE SELECTION OF COUNTERTOP STAND MIXERS

TILT-HEAD STAND MIXER

MINI TILT-HEAD STAND MIXER

BOWL-LIFT STAND MIXER

COUNTERTOP STAND MIXER COLORS FOR ANY DECÓR

*Attachments sold separately.

Shop Stand Mixer Attachments

Traditional Hot Cross Buns recipe

Yield: 12 buns | Prep: 2.5 hrs | Cook: 20 mins

Ingredients

Dough:

500g (4 cups) bread flour
75g (⅓ cup) caster sugar
1 tsp salt
7g instant yeast
2 tsp mixed spice (or 1 tsp cinnamon + ½ tsp nutmeg + ½ tsp allspice)
150ml (⅔ cup) warm milk
50g (¼ cup) melted butter
2 eggs, beaten
150g (1 cup) currants/raisins
50g (⅓ cup) mixed citrus peel

Pastry cross:

75g (½ cup) flour
100ml (⅓ cup + 1 tbsp) water

For an Icing cross:

100g (1 cup) powdered sugar
2–3 tbsp milk or water
½ tsp vanilla extract

Glaze:

2 tbsp apricot jam + 1 tbsp water (heated)

Step-by-step instructions

Activate yeast: Mix warm milk, sugar, and yeast; let sit 5 mins until frothy.
Combine dough: In a bowl, mix flour, salt, spices, yeast mixture, butter, and eggs. Knead 10 mins until elastic.
Add fruit: Fold in currants and peel. Let rise 1.5 hrs in a warm place until doubled.
Shape buns: Divide dough into 12 balls; place on a lined tray. Rest 30 mins.
Apply cross: Mix flour and water into a paste; pipe crosses onto buns.
Bake: 190°C/375°F for 18–20 mins until golden.
Glaze: Brush warm buns with jam mixture.

(Optional) Icing cross:

Whisk powdered sugar, vanilla, and 2 tbsp milk/water. Add more liquid ½ tsp at a time until thick but pipeable.
Transfer to a piping bag or ziplock with a snipped corner. Pipe crosses onto cooled buns (prevents melting).

Pro tips for success

Yeast check: Ensure milk is lukewarm (37°C/98°F) to avoid killing yeast.
Even baking: Space buns 2cm apart for soft sides.
Storage: Freeze for up to 3 months; refresh in a 160°C/320°F oven.
Soften dried fruit: Plump raisins in warm water or tea for 10 minutes before adding for juicier bites.
Sticky icing fix: If icing is too runny, add more powdered sugar; if too thick, add drops of liquid.
Flavour boost: Add 1 tsp cinnamon or a pinch of saffron to the dough for extra warmth.

Modern variations & dietary tweaks

Vegan: Substitute milk with almond milk, butter with coconut oil, and eggs with flax eggs.
Gluten-free: Use a 1:1 gluten-free flour blend.
Flavour twists: Add orange zest, chocolate chips, or dried cranberries.

Serving & symbolism

Serve warm with butter. Historically shared on Good Friday, the cross is said to ward off evil, and buns baked on Easter were believed to never mould.

KitchenAid 30-Inch 5 Burner Electric Double Oven Convection Range

Key Features • Even-Heat™ True Convection • 6.7 Cu. Ft. Total Capacity • Professionally-Inspired Design • 5 Cooking Elements Including a Warm Zone • EasyConvect™ Conversion System

Why we love hot cross buns

This recipe honours centuries of tradition while inviting creativity. Whether for Easter or a cosy treat, hot cross buns bridge ancient rituals and modern kitchens.

__________________________