Dive into the growing trend of charging parents for their children's crimes.

Photo by RDNE Stock Project on Pexels.com.

The emerging legal trend: Charging parents for children’s crimes

The United States is witnessing a growing trend charging parents for children’s crimes, particularly in cases of severe crimes such as school shootings. This shift reflects a broader societal debate over parental responsibility and the extent to which parents should be held accountable for their children’s actions. In two recent school shootings, the parents were charged alongside their children, raising questions about the efficacy and ethics of this approach.

Recent school shootings that resulted in charging parents for children’s crimes

Oxford High School shooting (Michigan, 2021)

In a tragic shooting at Oxford High School in Michigan, 15-year-old Ethan Crumbley killed four students and injured several others. His parents, James and Jennifer Crumbley, were charged with involuntary manslaughter, a rare move in school shooting cases.

Prosecutors argued that the parents were grossly negligent for providing Ethan access to the gun used in the shooting. They allegedly ignored warning signs, such as disturbing drawings and behaviours, and failed to intervene, even though school officials had alerted them to potential risks. The Crumbleys’ case set a precedent for holding parents criminally liable for failing to prevent their children from committing violent crimes.

Santa Clarita shooting (California, 2019)

Another notable case occurred in 2019, when a 16-year-old student opened fire at Saugus High School in Santa Clarita, California, killing two students and injuring three others. The shooter’s father, who had previously been subject to a restraining order preventing him from possessing firearms, was later charged with illegally acquiring and storing the gun his son used.

While the legal argument in this case focussed on the father’s violation of firearm laws, it reinforced the idea that parents could be held accountable for providing access to weapons used in violent crimes by their children.

Arguments for charging parents for children’s crimes

Parental responsibility

Advocates of this legal trend argue that parents have a moral and legal obligation to control and monitor their children’s behaviour, especially when it involves dangerous weapons or clear warning signs of violent tendencies.

In the Crumbley case, the parents were aware of their son’s troubling behaviour but failed to take preventive measures. Charging parents alongside their children can serve as a deterrent to negligent parenting, particularly in cases where access to firearms or other tools of violence plays a crucial role.

Encouraging accountability

By holding parents accountable, the justice system can promote a culture of responsibility. Parents who do not properly store firearms or neglect their children’s mental health needs can be seen as complicit in the crimes committed. Criminal charges against parents may compel them to take greater responsibility in the upbringing and safety of their children, fostering a more proactive approach to preventing violence.

Preventive effect

If parents are aware that they could face criminal charges for their children’s actions, they may be more vigilant in identifying warning signs and intervening before a crime occurs. This legal trend could potentially lead to a reduction in juvenile crime, particularly in cases involving firearms.

Preventive measures like secure firearm storage, better communication between schools and parents, and mental health interventions could become more widespread as a result.

Swann – Master Series 8-Channel, 8-Camera, Indoor/Outdoor PoE Wired 4K UHD 2TB HDD NVR Security Surveillance System

Buy Now

Arguments against charging parents for children’s crimes

Blaming the parent for the child’s actions

Critics argue that holding parents responsible for their children’s crimes can unfairly shift the blame. In some cases, even attentive and responsible parents may find it impossible to foresee or prevent violent behaviour.

While the parents in the Crumbley case were arguably negligent, not every parent is in control of their child’s actions or aware of the severity of potential threats. Children, especially teenagers, may conceal their intentions or mental health struggles, leaving parents unaware.

Potential overreach of legal boundaries

Charging parents for their children’s crimes risks expanding legal boundaries in ways that could lead to broader criminal liability for parental behaviour.

Critics warn that this could result in a slippery slope where parents are held accountable for a wide range of juvenile misbehaviour, even when they have done their best to prevent it.

Legal overreach in these cases could lead to wrongful convictions or excessive punishment for parents who may already be struggling with the challenges of raising a troubled child.

Focus on punishment rather than prevention

Instead of criminalising parents, some argue that more attention should be given to systemic issues such as mental health, school safety, and access to firearms.

Criminal charges may do little to address the underlying causes of juvenile violence, such as inadequate mental health resources or the proliferation of guns.

Rather than focussing on punishment after the fact, society should prioritise preventive solutions that can address the root causes of youth violence.

Swann – Master Series 16-Channel, 10-Camera, Indoor/Outdoor PoE Wired 4K UHD 2TB HDD NVR Security Surveillance System

Buy Now

The role of parental tools in preventing juvenile crimes

As the legal trend of charging parents alongside their children gains momentum, it becomes increasingly important for parents to take proactive measures in safeguarding their children from harmful external influences.

One such preventive tool is Kaspersky Safe Kids, a comprehensive parental control software designed to protect children from digital dangers. Rather than focussing solely on punitive measures after a crime has occurred, utilising protective technologies like Kaspersky Safe Kids offers parents the opportunity to shield their children from potential risks early on.

Features of Kaspersky Safe Kids

Kaspersky Safe Kids is equipped with a variety of features that can help parents monitor and guide their children’s online activities, contributing to safer and healthier development:

Real-time GPS tracking: Parents can track their child’s location in real time, ensuring they are aware of their whereabouts. Alerts can also be set if the child enters or leaves specific areas.
Internet filtering: The software allows parents to block inappropriate websites and content, including those related to violence, drugs, and explicit material, which are often linked to negative behavioral influences.
App usage controls: Parents can manage the types of apps their children use, set time limits for specific apps, and block harmful apps, preventing exposure to dangerous games or social platforms.
Social media monitoring: Kaspersky Safe Kids monitors the child’s activity on social media platforms, helping parents spot potential risks such as cyberbullying, predatory behaviour, or exposure to harmful content.
Screen time management: It allows parents to set daily screen time limits and restrict device use during certain hours, encouraging a balanced digital life and reducing overexposure to negative influences.
Detailed reports: Parents receive insights into their child’s online behaviour, including browsing history, search queries, and social media interactions, helping them identify warning signs of potential issues early on.

Payment options for Kaspersky Safe Kids

Kaspersky Safe Kids offers flexible payment options to accommodate different family needs:

Free version: The basic version includes essential tools like web filtering, app control, and screen time management. This version provides core protection without cost, making it accessible to all families.
Premium version: The premium version includes more advanced features like GPS tracking, social media monitoring, and detailed reporting. The premium plan costs approximately $15 annually, providing comprehensive coverage at an affordable price.
Family bundle: Kaspersky also offers bundled plans that combine their antivirus software with parental controls, creating a full protection package for both devices and children’s digital safety.

The benefits of early protection

Implementing protective measures such as Kaspersky Safe Kids from an early age can help prevent children from being exposed to harmful external influences, both online and offline.

Mitigating negative influences: By blocking access to violent content, inappropriate websites, and risky social media interactions, parents can reduce the likelihood that their children will be influenced by dangerous behaviours, such as violence, drug use, or bullying.
Fostering healthy habits: Setting time limits on app usage and screen time encourages children to develop healthier digital habits. This can prevent overexposure to harmful online cultures, such as those promoting aggression or negative body image.
Encouraging open dialogue: The detailed reports and insights offered by tools like Kaspersky Safe Kids give parents the opportunity to have informed discussions with their children. Open dialogue can help children understand the risks associated with certain online behaviors and develop critical thinking skills.
Preventing future legal issues: Early intervention in a child’s exposure to harmful influences could reduce the risk of involvement in illegal activities, potentially preventing the types of juvenile crimes that lead to legal consequences for both children and their parents.

Bachelor (B.Sc) Applied Artificial Intelligence

Online Study Model Degree Bachelor of Science (B.Sc.) 180 ECTS credits Language English Tuition Fees & Discounts Tuition Fees Starting from 130 € (131 $)* per month *based on the exchange rate from 01.07.2023 09:05 AM (CEST) Discounts Discounts and promotions are available on a seasonal basis Online application No application fees Study Duration Study start any time Duration36 – 72 months (depending on time model)

Conclusion

While the legal system continues to debate the role of parents in their children’s crimes, taking early, proactive steps to protect children from negative influences may be a more effective way to prevent these situations from occurring in the first place. Kaspersky Safe Kids, with its robust set of features and accessible pricing, offers parents the tools they need to create a safer, more controlled environment for their children, ultimately fostering responsible digital and real-world behaviour.

_______________________________