Why your printer now comes with a monthly bill and how to escape it.

From ownership to obligation: How the subscription model took over everyday life and what it means for your printer

The quiet shift from buying to subscribing

There was a time when buying something meant owning it outright. You paid once, took it home, used it until it wore out, then replaced it on your own terms. That model defined consumer culture for most of the twentieth century. Today, it has been steadily replaced by something far more restrictive. Across industries, from software and entertainment to transport, fitness, food delivery and even household appliances, ownership has given way to subscription. Instead of a single transaction, consumers are locked into recurring payments that never truly end.

This shift did not happen overnight. It has been driven by changes in manufacturing, digital infrastructure and corporate finance. Companies increasingly favour predictable, recurring revenue over one-off sales. Subscriptions smooth cash flow, boost long-term valuations and keep customers tethered to a brand. What began with newspapers and utilities has now spread to products that were once simple, mechanical and self-contained. Printers are one of the clearest and most controversial examples of this transformation.

EcoTank Supertank Refillable Ink Tank Printers

Actual savings of money, waste, and hassle will vary. Cost of printing (printer + ink) comparison based on included ink bottles vs. included and replacement ink cartridges over 3 years using average monthly print volumes. For more information see below.

A brief history of subscriptions before the digital age

Subscriptions are not new. In the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, newspapers, journals and book serials relied on prepaid readers to fund printing and distribution. Milk delivery, coal supply and later telephone services followed similar models. In each case, the subscription made sense because the product was consumed continuously. You did not buy a lifetime supply of newspapers or electricity. You paid for access over time.

The late twentieth century saw subscriptions expand into cable television and mobile phone contracts. Even then, the core product remained usable without constant permission from the provider. A television worked without a cable package. A phone could make basic calls without add-ons. The subscription enhanced the experience rather than controlled the object itself.

The digital revolution changed that balance. Software companies realised they could move from selling boxed products to licensing access. Adobe, Microsoft and others led the charge. Consumers lost perpetual ownership in exchange for updates and cloud features. Many accepted the trade-off because the tools improved rapidly and became central to modern work.

How physical products became services

The more troubling shift came when physical products adopted software-style subscription controls. Cars now ship with hardware features locked behind monthly payments. Smart home devices rely on cloud services that can be withdrawn or repriced at any time. Fitness equipment, once a one-off investment, increasingly demands ongoing fees to function fully.

Printers sit at the heart of this trend. They appear to be simple machines, yet modern models are tightly integrated with software, firmware updates and online accounts. This integration has allowed manufacturers to reshape the economics of printing in ways that benefit them far more than the user.

HP and the printer subscription playbook

HP’s printer and ink subscription programme is often cited as the clearest example of subscription overreach. On the surface, the offer sounds convenient. Instead of buying ink cartridges as needed, customers pay a monthly fee based on the number of pages they print. Ink is delivered automatically before it runs out. Predictable costs and no last-minute trips to the shop are the selling points.

The reality is more complex. Under this model, the printer monitors usage and reports back to HP. The cartridges provided through the programme are tied to the subscription. If the customer cancels, the cartridges stop working, even if there is ink left inside them. Printing beyond the allotted page count incurs additional charges. Firmware updates can restrict the use of third-party ink entirely.

What was once a device you controlled becomes a gatekept service. The printer is no longer fully yours, despite being physically present in your home or office. HP has effectively turned ink, a consumable, into a metered utility under its control.

The economics behind the ink trap

To understand why this model exists, it helps to look at printer pricing. For decades, printers have been sold at or near cost. The profit came from ink cartridges, which are among the most marked-up consumer products in the world. Subscriptions take this logic further by guaranteeing lifetime ink revenue.

For light users, the monthly fee may appear reasonable. For families, students, small businesses or anyone who prints regularly, costs can escalate quickly. Over several years, the total spend on ink subscriptions can exceed the cost of the printer many times over. Worse, the consumer loses flexibility. Missed payments, account issues or regional service changes can leave a perfectly functional printer unable to print a single page.

Why consumers keep accepting subscriptions

Despite widespread frustration, subscription models continue to spread. Part of the reason is psychological. Low monthly fees feel easier to accept than high upfront costs, even when the long-term total is higher. Marketing emphasises convenience and peace of mind rather than control and value.

Another factor is lack of transparency. Many buyers do not realise the limitations until they are already invested. Printers are often purchased during sales, bundled with trial subscriptions that quietly convert into paid plans. By the time the implications become clear, switching feels inconvenient.

A different approach to printing

Not all manufacturers have embraced this path. Epson has taken a notably different approach with its EcoTank family of printers. Rather than locking users into cartridge subscriptions, EcoTank printers use large, refillable ink tanks. Ink is purchased in bottles and poured directly into the printer. There are no chips to disable printing, no page limits and no mandatory accounts.

This design returns control to the user. You buy ink when you need it. You choose how much you print. The printer functions independently of any subscription service. While the upfront cost of an EcoTank printer is typically higher than a cartridge-based model, the long-term savings are substantial.

Understanding the EcoTank economics

Epson estimates that a single set of EcoTank ink bottles can print thousands of pages, often equivalent to dozens of traditional cartridges. The cost per page drops dramatically, particularly for colour printing. Over time, the higher purchase price is offset by lower running costs.

For households and small offices, this difference is not marginal. It can amount to hundreds of pounds or dollars saved each year, alongside the less tangible benefit of autonomy.

EcoTank ET-2980: the smart home office choice

The EcoTank ET-2980 Wireless All-in-One Colour Supertank Printer is well suited to home users, students and remote workers. It handles everyday documents, school assignments and occasional colour printing with ease. For a typical household printing around 200 pages per month, an HP-style subscription could cost the equivalent of US$10 to US$15 per month, or roughly US$120 to US$180 per year.

With the ET-2980, annual ink costs for the same volume are closer to US$20 to US$30 once the initial bottles are used. That translates to annual savings in the region of US$100 to US$150, while avoiding subscription lock-in entirely.

EcoTank ET-3930: reliable volume for busy households

The EcoTank ET-3930 steps up performance and durability, making it a strong fit for busy families or home-based businesses. It offers faster printing and higher duty cycles. At 400 to 500 pages per month, subscription plans often jump into higher pricing tiers, pushing annual ink costs to US$250 or more.

EcoTank ink for this volume typically costs under US$40 per year after the initial supply. The annual saving can reach US$200 or more, with consistent print quality and no artificial limits.

EcoTank ET-3950: small business efficiency without strings

The EcoTank ET-3950 is designed for heavier workloads, making it ideal for small offices, community organisations or freelancers who print invoices, marketing materials and reports regularly. At 800 to 1,000 pages per month, subscription-based ink costs can exceed US$400 annually, especially when overage fees are factored in.

The ET-3950 can handle this volume with ink costs closer to US$60 per year. Annual savings of US$300 or more are realistic, alongside reduced downtime and fewer interruptions from cartridge changes or account issues.

More than money: control, resilience and trust

The financial case for EcoTank printers is compelling, yet the deeper issue is control. Subscription-based hardware shifts power away from the user. It introduces dependency into objects that should be reliable tools. In an era where internet outages, account suspensions and policy changes are common, resilience matters.

A printer should print when you need it, regardless of your billing status or firmware update history. EcoTank printers restore that expectation. They work offline. They accept third-party paper and standard workflows. They behave like appliances rather than terminals in a corporate revenue system.

The broader lesson of the subscription economy

Printers are a microcosm of a larger trend. As subscriptions spread, consumers are increasingly paying for permission rather than ownership. This model is unlikely to disappear, but it can be resisted through informed choices. Supporting products that prioritise transparency and long-term value sends a signal to the market.

The subscription economy thrives on inertia. Breaking free often requires a deliberate decision to pay more upfront in exchange for independence later. In the case of printers, that decision is easier than most.

A practical way forward

For anyone frustrated by monthly ink fees, page limits and locked cartridges, the solution is not complicated. Choosing a printer that treats ink as a consumable rather than a service changes the entire experience. Epson’s EcoTank range demonstrates that modern printers do not need subscriptions to be efficient, reliable or profitable.

In a world where almost everything seems to come with a monthly bill, the simple act of buying a printer that you truly own becomes quietly radical. It saves money, reduces stress and restores a sense of agency that has been steadily eroded. When it comes to the most searched-for office device in the world, the printer, that shift matters more than ever.

______________________