AI and literacy: Why machine-generated language is undermining how we learn to read.

AI and literacy: How long-term use artificial intelligence is negatively affecting literacy

Artificial intelligence has moved from novelty to infrastructure in less than a decade. It now mediates how people search, read, write, summarise, interpret and even feel. For adults, this shift often presents itself as convenience. For children and young users, it represents something far more consequential: a restructuring of how literacy is acquired, practised and sustained.

The conversation around AI and literacy is frequently framed in terms of access and efficiency, yet far less attention is given to the cognitive costs of sustained reliance on machine-generated language. When reading, writing and comprehension are outsourced to automated systems over long periods, the very skills that define literacy begin to erode.

Literacy is not passive exposure to words. It is an active, effortful process that requires decoding, interpretation, memory, inference and synthesis. These mental acts strengthen neural pathways in the brain, particularly during childhood and adolescence, when cognitive development is most plastic. AI systems that summarise texts, simplify language or generate responses on demand remove the friction that literacy requires in order to grow. Over time, this removal of effort does not leave reading skills untouched. It weakens them.

Big Kid Books

(5 book series)

Are you tired of endless flashcards that don’t translate into real-world reading success? For many children and adults, traditional methods like flashcards and dry word lists simply do not work. It is easy to feel stuck and defeated when words do not sound the way they look.

Technological shifts and the pattern of cognitive change

Throughout history, major communication technologies have altered how human beings think. The printing press externalised memory into books. Radio and television shifted cognition towards audio-visual processing.

The internet introduced what psychologists later described as the “Google effect”, where people became less likely to remember information they knew they could retrieve instantly. AI represents the next and most profound step in this pattern because it does not merely store or transmit information. It interprets, rephrases and produces language in place of the user.

This distinction matters. Previous technologies extended human capacity. AI increasingly replaces it. When a child asks an AI system to explain a text rather than working through the language, vocabulary and structure themselves, the brain does not engage in the same way.

Over time, repeated avoidance of cognitive effort creates what researchers describe as cognitive debt. Mental work deferred in the short term is paid for later through reduced reasoning ability, weaker comprehension and diminished intellectual independence.

Literacy as a skill built through difficulty

Reading comprehension improves through exposure to challenging material. Encountering unfamiliar words, complex sentence structures and abstract ideas forces the reader to slow down, infer meaning, consult references and reflect. This process is not a flaw in literacy education. It is the mechanism by which literacy develops. AI tools that promise instant understanding by simplifying or summarising texts short-circuit this process.

For young users, the effect is particularly damaging. A child who grows accustomed to AI explanations never builds the tolerance for difficulty that reading demands. When difficulty arises, the conditioned response is not persistence but delegation. Over time, this creates readers who are dependent on mediation. They can process information only after it has been filtered, reduced and reshaped by a machine. This is not improved literacy. It is a narrowed form of consumption that collapses when assistance is removed.

Reading without remembering

One of the most concerning findings emerging from early studies on AI-assisted reading and writing is the decline in retention. When users rely on AI to generate or summarise text, they often struggle to recall what they have read or written shortly afterwards. This is not surprising. Memory formation is closely tied to effort. The brain remembers what it has worked to understand.

Young users who rely on AI tools for school assignments, comprehension tasks or note-taking may appear productive, yet they frequently retain little of the material. Over time, this undermines academic confidence and intellectual autonomy. Literacy becomes something performed by a system rather than embodied by the learner.

Vocabulary decline and language narrowing

Vocabulary growth depends on repeated exposure to words in varied contexts. AI systems tend to reduce linguistic range rather than expand it. Their outputs prioritise clarity and predictability, often relying on a narrower band of commonly used words. When children consume large volumes of AI-generated or AI-simplified text, their exposure to rich, varied language decreases.

This narrowing effect has long-term consequences. A reduced vocabulary limits reading comprehension, expressive writing and critical thinking. It also affects emotional articulation. Young people who lack words struggle to name experiences, emotions and ideas with precision. Over time, this constrains thought itself.

The illusion of understanding

One of the most dangerous effects of AI-mediated reading is the illusion of comprehension. AI summaries often provide a surface-level understanding that feels complete. The reader believes they understand the text because the explanation is smooth and accessible. Yet the underlying arguments, nuances and complexities remain untouched.

This illusion is particularly harmful in educational contexts. Students may perform well on simplified assessments while lacking the depth of understanding required for advanced learning. When they later encounter material that cannot be easily summarised or simplified, they struggle. The foundation was never built.

Improve Spelling and Reading Skills

(10 books)

This is a series of fun spelling books available in both e-book and paperback formats. These books are designed for various educational purposes, including story time, spelling improvement classes, poetry sessions, and reading intervention programs, as they help improve phonological and phonemic awareness. The books contain stories filled with words that have rimes containing digraphs, trigraphs, and 4-letter graphemes.

Available on Kindle and Paperback

Cognitive load, cognitive debt and the developing brain

AI tools are frequently marketed as reducing cognitive load. While this may be appropriate for certain tasks, sustained reduction of cognitive load during learning has negative effects. The developing brain requires challenge to strengthen executive function, attention span and reasoning capacity.

Research cited in the transcript highlights how external cognitive support, particularly from language models, reduces brain activation during tasks that would otherwise require sustained mental effort. Over time, this pattern leads to dependency. The brain adapts to a lower level of engagement and struggles when required to operate independently.

Literacy and the boundary between thought and tool

Perhaps the subtlest impact of long-term AI use is the erosion of the boundary between personal thought and machine-generated output. When young users rely on AI to formulate opinions, explain ideas or articulate feelings, they gradually lose clarity about where their own thinking ends and the machine’s begins.

Literacy is not only about decoding text. It is about forming and expressing original thought. When this process is mediated by AI from an early age, intellectual identity becomes blurred. The child does not practise thinking through language. They practise selecting from machine-generated options.

Drums

Oval Blue Eyeglasses

by EyeBuyDirect

US$6.

Buy Now

Why this matters for society

Literacy underpins democratic participation, scientific understanding, cultural continuity and personal agency. A population that can read deeply, think critically and articulate ideas independently is resilient. A population that relies on automated systems to interpret reality is vulnerable.

The long-term risks of declining literacy extend beyond education. They affect employment, civic engagement and mental health. Individuals who struggle to read complex material are more susceptible to manipulation, misinformation and oversimplified narratives. AI systems that prioritise ease over depth accelerate this vulnerability.

Rebuilding literacy through reading, not avoiding It

The solution is not the rejection of technology, but the restoration of reading as an active practice. Children and young readers need sustained exposure to age-appropriate yet challenging texts that require engagement. They need to read without summaries, struggle with meaning, and build confidence through mastery.

Books designed to support literacy development play a crucial role here. Structured reading programmes that emphasise vocabulary growth, comprehension and spelling help rebuild the skills that AI use can weaken.

A practical recommendation for parents and educators

For families and educators concerned about the effects of AI on reading and understanding, structured reading resources provide an effective counterbalance. The Big Kid Books – 5 Book Series offers age-appropriate narratives that encourage independent reading and comprehension without artificial mediation. Similarly, the Improve Spelling and Reading Skills – 10 Book Series supports foundational literacy through consistent practice and progressive challenge.

These series, developed by studyzoneinstitute.com, focus on the very skills that sustained AI use undermines: vocabulary acquisition, spelling accuracy, reading stamina and comprehension depth. Used regularly, they help young readers rebuild confidence in their own abilities and re-establish reading as an internal process rather than an outsourced one.

Choosing literacy over convenience

AI will remain part of modern life. The question is not whether it exists, but how it is used. When artificial intelligence becomes a substitute for reading, thinking and understanding, literacy suffers. For young users, the cost is particularly high because the habits formed early shape cognitive development for life.

The evidence emerging from research and observation is clear. Long-term dependence on AI for reading and writing weakens comprehension, reduces vocabulary, impairs memory and creates cognitive dependency. These effects are not inevitable. They are the result of choices.

By prioritising real reading, structured literacy practice and books that challenge rather than simplify, parents and educators can protect and strengthen the skills that define human intelligence. In an age of artificial language, choosing to read deeply is an act of preservation.

_______________