Learn how to calculate profit for tax purposes even if you have mixed personal and business expenses.

Messy books? How to calculate profit and fix comingled expenses for tax season

Small business owners often start with a dream of independence and a passion for their craft. Whether you are a hairdresser, a plumber, or a graphic artist, the line between your personal life and your business often becomes blurred. In the rush of a busy day, it is incredibly easy to use the cash a client just handed you to buy a supermarket meal deal or to use the company van for a weekend trip to the beach with the kids. This practice is known as comingling, and while it feels convenient in the moment, it creates a massive headache when tax season arrives.

The problem with comingling is that the tax authorities require a clear distinction between what the business earned and what you spent on yourself. If you have not kept a single receipt or tracked your mileage, you are essentially flying blind. You might end up paying more tax than you owe because you cannot prove your expenses, or worse, you could face heavy penalties for underreporting your income.

Calculating profit under these circumstances feels like trying to unbake a cake to find the original eggs and flour. However, even if your records are currently a mess of grocery receipts and business invoices, there are ways to reconstruct your finances and get back on the right track.

Save on expert tax prep and filing

We recommend Taxfyle for expert tax prep, filing, and advice. Claim an exclusive discount by booking with your Rocket Lawyer account.

A guide to calculating profit and fixing comingled finances

Reconstruct your income through bank statements

The first step in fixing a financial mess is to determine exactly how much money came into your world. You should gather every bank statement from every account you used, including personal accounts where clients might have sent transfers. Look at every deposit and highlight the ones that came from customers. If you received cash payments that never hit the bank, you will need to look at your calendar or appointment book to estimate how many jobs you completed. This creates a baseline for your “Gross Income”, which is the total amount of money your business earned before any spending occurred.

Once you have a total for the money coming in, you must be honest about any cash that went straight into your pocket. If you are a barber who took fifty dollars in tips and spent it on dinner, that fifty dollars is still part of your business income. Documenting this income is the foundation of calculating profit because profit is simply what is left over after you subtract your legitimate business expenses from this total. Without an accurate income figure, any further calculations will be flawed and could lead to trouble with tax officials.

Identify and categorise every direct business expense

After establishing your income, you need to go through your spending to find the “Direct Expenses”. These are costs that were purely for the business, such as buying hair dye for a salon or timber for a construction job. Even if you paid for these using a personal credit card, they are still deductible business expenses that reduce your taxable profit. You should look for recurring payments to suppliers or software subscriptions that are clearly linked to your professional work.

If you do not have the physical receipts, you can often find digital records or request copies from your suppliers. In the eyes of tax collectors, a bank transaction showing a payment to a known trade supplier is much better than having no record at all. By isolating these clear business costs, you begin to chip away at that gross income figure. This process helps you move toward your “Net Profit”, which is the actual amount of money the business made after the costs of doing business are removed.

Apply the percentage method for shared assets

Comingling often involves assets that serve two purposes, like a mobile phone or a home internet connection. If you use your phone for fifty percent business calls and fifty percent personal scrolling, you cannot claim the entire bill as a business expense. To solve this without an accountant, you should look at a typical week of usage and decide on a reasonable percentage that represents your business use. For example, if you are a graphic artist working from home, you might determine that forty percent of your electricity and internet is dedicated to your studio.

Once you have settled on a fair percentage, apply that to the total bills for the year. If your annual internet bill was six hundred dollars and you used it half the time for work, you can claim three hundred dollars as a business expense. It is important to be realistic and conservative with these percentages. If you claim that your home heater is ninety percent for business use but you only work four hours a day, a tax auditor will likely find that unreasonable and disallow the claim entirely.

Calculate business mileage using a logbook reconstruction

For tradesmen and taxi drivers, the vehicle is often the largest shared expense. If you use the same van for work and for family outings, you must separate the miles. The easiest way to fix this after the fact is to look at your total mileage for the year via your service records or MOT history and then look at your work diary. By mapping out the locations of the jobs you attended, you can estimate the distance travelled for business purposes.

Most tax jurisdictions allow you to claim a flat rate per mile or a percentage of actual vehicle costs like fuel and insurance. If you choose the percentage route, you divide your business miles by your total miles to find your business use ratio. For instance, if you drove ten thousand miles in total and seven thousand were for work, you can claim seventy percent of your vehicle running costs. This calculation is vital because vehicle expenses often represent a significant portion of a small business owner’s deductions.

324465828 506060108184794 4926160049931162859 n

With Rocket Tax, taxes aren’t taxing

Fast & easy Sign and upload documents in minutes on your phone, and get your taxes done fast — 7 days, on average. Attorney expertise Does your tax situation require legal guidance? Our network attorneys can share all the ins and outs. Saves you money Experts agree — using a pro reduces your risk of errors and audits. Plus, you get all the credits you deserve. Half off! Did we mention Rocket Legal+ members get HALF OFF? Upgrade now or join today and start saving!

Use the square footage method for home offices

If you are an entertainer or a freelancer who uses a portion of your home for practice or administration, you can claim a portion of your rent or mortgage interest. You should measure the total square footage of your home and then measure the specific area used for your business. If your office takes up ten percent of your home’s total area, then ten percent of your housing costs can generally be considered a business expense. This is a simple way to legally reduce your taxable profit using costs you are already paying.

However, you must ensure the space is actually used for business. Using the dining room table for an hour a day while the family eats there later does not usually count as a dedicated business space in many regions. If the space is shared, you may need to perform a second calculation based on the number of hours the room is used for work versus personal life. This dual-layer calculation ensures that you are not over-claiming and provides a clear logic that you can explain if you are ever questioned by tax authorities.

Separate personal drawings from business costs

One of the biggest hurdles in comingled finances is the “Personal Drawing”. This happens when you use business money to buy groceries or pay for a personal holiday. These are not business expenses and do not reduce your profit; instead, they are simply you taking your pay out of the business. To fix your books, you must identify these transactions and label them clearly as personal drawings rather than business costs. This prevents you from accidentally claiming your weekly grocery shop as a tax deduction.

When you look at your bank statement and see a fifty dollar charge at a local cafe that was just for your lunch, you must mark that as personal. While it was paid for with business money, it is not a “necessary” expense for the operation of the business. By methodically labelling these personal withdrawals, you ensure that your final profit figure is accurate. This clarity is exactly what a tax office wants to see, as it shows you are not trying to hide personal lifestyle costs inside your business accounts.

Messy books? How to calculate profit and fix comingled expenses for tax season 7

File Taxes Online Yourself | Max Refund Guaranteed

Confidently file your own taxes online with trusted tools and step-by-step guidance. Max refund guaranteed with TaxAct DIY filing.

Document the use of personal funds for business

It is very common for small business owners to run out of money in the business account and use a personal credit card to buy supplies. If you do not track this, you are effectively overpaying your taxes because you are hiding expenses that should be lowering your profit. You should go through your personal statements and look for any payments made to business-related vendors. This might include a trip to a hardware store or a payment for a professional certification.

Once you find these, you should create a simple spreadsheet listing the date, the amount, and what was purchased. This acts as a “reimbursement” record. Even if the business never actually pays you back the cash, these amounts should be added to your total business expenses. By capturing these forgotten costs, you lower your taxable profit, which means you keep more of your hard-earned money. It is a simple fix that requires nothing more than a highlighter and a few hours of your time.

Establish a consistent record keeping system moving forward

The best way to fix a mess is to ensure it never happens again. You should immediately open a dedicated business bank account and commit to using it only for business transactions. When a customer pays you, the money goes there. When you need to buy supplies, the money comes from there. If you need money for groceries, you should transfer a lump sum from the business account to your personal account and label it as “Owner Pay” or “Salary”.

This creates a clean paper trail that requires no reconstruction at the end of the year. You can also use simple mobile apps that allow you to snap a photo of a receipt the moment you get it. This digital habit removes the need for shoe boxes full of paper and ensures that your expenses are organised in real time. For a busy tradesman or hairdresser, taking five seconds to photograph a receipt at the till saves hours of stress and potential financial loss during tax season.

Create a simple monthly profit and loss summary

You do not need to be an accountant to create a basic Profit and Loss statement. At the end of every month, you should spend thirty minutes adding up your total sales and subtracting your total business expenses. This gives you a monthly profit figure. By doing this regularly, you can see how your business is performing and you can set aside a portion of that profit for your future tax bill. This prevents the “tax season shock” where you realise you owe money that you have already spent.

This monthly habit also helps you spot trends, such as rising material costs or unnecessary subscriptions. It turns your finances from a scary mystery into a tool for growth. If you see that your profit is lower than expected, you can adjust your prices or cut back on spending before the problem becomes unmanageable. Clear definitions of your monthly earnings make the final annual calculation a simple matter of adding twelve numbers together rather than solving a year-long puzzle.

Understand the difference between assets and expenses

When you buy a large item like a professional printer or a new van, it is handled differently than a box of paper or a tank of fuel. These larger items are “Assets” and their cost is often spread out over several years through a process called depreciation. If you spent five thousand dollars on a new piece of equipment, you might not be able to subtract the whole amount from this year’s profit. You should check the local tax rules for “capital allowances” or “depreciation” to see how much of a large purchase you can claim each year.

Simple English definitions help here: an expense is something that is used up quickly, like electricity or shampoo. An asset is something that lasts for years and helps you make money over a long period. Correcting your books means making sure you haven’t listed a new car as a one-time expense. Categorising these correctly ensures your profit calculation is legally sound and prevents you from making errors that could trigger an audit. Once you understand this distinction, you can manage your big-ticket purchases much more effectively.

Conclusion

Calculating business profit when your personal and professional lives are intertwined is a challenging but necessary task. By methodically reconstructing your income, categorising your expenses, and separating your personal drawings, you can arrive at a figure that is fair and accurate. The key is to be honest with yourself about where the money went and to document your reasoning for any shared costs. While it may take a weekend of sorting through bank statements and old calendars, the peace of mind that comes with having an organised financial record is worth the effort.

Moving forward, the goal is to treat your business as a separate entity from yourself. By using dedicated accounts and tracking your mileage in real time, you transform from a stressed business owner into a confident professional. You do not need a degree in accounting to maintain clean books; you simply need a system that works for your daily routine. With these steps, you can focus on what you do best, whether that is building, creating, or serving your clients, knowing that your finances are under control and your taxes are handled correctly.

_______________